Losing my PDA

For a while now I’ve been a fan of the Moleskine notebook. My first step was to use the standard pocket version. A good source for these is at bureau.

I then branched out into the larger sketch book version. I attached Post-It labels for a GTD-like system of lists as part of it; the other pages are for notes, sketches, Mind Maps … and drafting blog posts (such as this one). This has begun to replace my electronic systems for personal organisation, although I still use MindManager, Outlook, OneNote and Firefox to file electronic material I come across or generate.

One of my favourite blogs is moleskinerie which is coming up to its second anniversary; it often stimulates me to creativity, but always through the traditional medium of pen and paper. A recent post referenced why techies are returning to paper.

Such a reversion to drafting ideas on paper is hugely inefficient – or so we are told … usually by systems sales people. My experience is otherwise. I find regularly abandoning my screen, which usually shows my In-box, is good for me. It is refreshing and clarifying.

I begin to set my ideas down on a rather less constraining portal – the pages of my moleskine – where I can sketch, doodle, and generally be stimulated by the visceral experience of feeling pen on paper. It is ‘thinking at the speed of write’.

Yes, I can do much of this on my Tablet PC using MindManager and OneNote; and as a natural technophile I have tried very hard to be faithful to these. I really do appreciate these systems.

But there is something altogether more liberating about the primitive medium of pen and paper. I can’t altogether explain why. It’s almost an existential thing. You have to experience it; and by the measure of the buzz around the moleskine and the Hipster PDA, many have discovered for themselves the same experience.

So I’ve abandoned my PDA – and if you want to know which model it is then that is a sign you’ve not really bought into what I’ve been trying to say. I now have a simple pocket Moleskine week-to-a-view diary that has a separate address book pull-out at the back. (I can anticipate the groans from all PDA fans…) And I feel a lot better for it.

No, paper notebooks and paper diaries are never perfect; they have their own limitations. But their limitations are better known, they are more trustworthy, more flexible, and less bland than their electronic equivalents.

My last step in this process of technical reversion was to go back to my PDA and do one last synchronisation with my PC…. only to find that the battery had died from a few days’ neglect and it had wiped the memory.

I’m sure it’s a God thing. I’m not supposed to go back.

 

Comments

[Robin Mayfield]

Ironically enough the only thing I find myself doing with my PDA these days is using it to read e-books.

[PatrickMayfield]

Tim,
That's interesting, but I don't think you have gone quite as 'retro'. Your use of the XDA is pretty cool stuff, composing pages for your moblog.

Patrick ;-)

[Tim Smithies]

Ha!
I knew you would!
I've kinda done the same though. Although in reverse, I carry an XDA2s gadget which does PDA things, internet and phone but if it comes to ideas and jottings then I use one of the pocket Moleskines (just got one of those nice new storyboard ones too!) as I hate exploring ideas on the PDA. Mind you - I don't use my tablet PC much at all anymore either - it's the XDA and the Moleskine.

As an avid PDA junkie since the early Psions (May they rest in peace... a moments silence please) it's only the last generation of devices that can do WiFi, GPRS, email etc and cameras that I can use for my moblog that I've liked them as much as the old ones. I can understand that using one just for contacts and diary isn't that appealing these days (especially if you are still carrying a phone too) as well as a Moleskine... I don't take two gadgets into the shower any more, and find that my XDA2s is taking over from the laptop on short trips/jobs etc... and of course it can read blogs on the go!

Tim ;-)

[Patrick]

Nick,
Please see my later post (today). I think I am forging some kind of symbiosis between electronic and paper-based media that suits me.
What sparks one's creativity and what suits one's individual working style is ultimately a very personal thing. I admire people who only need to work through their PCs, but I am discovering that I am not one of them.
As I admitted in my post, I'm not sure it's an entirely rational thing.

[Nick Duffill]

Patrick
What would you say was the underlying cause of the back-to-basics trend? Is it because technology fails to deliver, or because it is so unforgiving of our imperfections, and holds up a distorted mirror?